RankingsBased on 159 vehicles analyzed

Most Reliable Midsize Trucks (Ranked)

Best midsize pickup trucks for long-term reliability and low cost of ownership.

#1
92
1995 Toyota TacomaLOWA-

A truly bulletproof truck if you find a rust-free example and address known safety recalls and wear items proactively.

#2
92
1997 Toyota TacomaLOWA-

A legendary workhorse, but frame rust is its Achilles' heel; inspect thoroughly or regret it.

#3
92
1996 Toyota TacomaLOWA-

A legendary workhorse that will run forever, provided its Achilles' heel of frame rust is addressed and basic maintenance is observed.

#4
92
1998 Toyota TacomaMODA-

A mechanically bulletproof truck with a potentially terminal rust problem, making diligent inspection paramount.

#5
92
1999 Toyota TacomaLOWA

A nearly indestructible truck if you manage its Achilles' heel: frame integrity.

#6
92
2000 Toyota TacomaLOWA-

A truly reliable workhorse, but frame rust is a deal-breaker if not already addressed or pristine.

#7
92
2002 Toyota TacomaLOWA-

A nearly bulletproof compact truck, provided you meticulously inspect the frame and suspension components for critical weaknesses.

#8
92
2010 Ford RangerLOWA-

A no-frills, highly dependable compact truck that prioritizes utility and longevity over luxury, making it a smart buy if rust is absent.

#9
92
2024 Honda RidgelineLOWA

A supremely reliable and comfortable truck that defies common pickup truck reliability issues.

#10
91
2003 Toyota TacomaLOWA

A legendary workhorse that will outlast its owners, provided the frame isn't eaten by rust.

#11
91
2016 Honda RidgelineLOWA-

A clever, highly reliable truck alternative that consistently delivers utility and comfort with few major headaches.

#12
91
2025 Honda RidgelineLOWA-

A supremely reliable and practical unibody pickup that offers peace of mind for years to come.

#13
90
2007 Honda RidgelineLOWA-

A highly capable and robust unibody truck offering Honda's legendary reliability with proper, scheduled maintenance.

#14
90
2019 Honda RidgelineLOWA-

The 2019 Ridgeline is a smart, low-risk buy offering minivan-like comfort with pickup versatility.

#15
89
2021 Toyota TacomaLOWA-

A top-tier choice for reliability, despite some persistent drivability and technology annoyances.

#16
89
2015 Toyota TacomaMODA-

A legendary workhorse, but its Achilles' heel is frame rust – inspect thoroughly or proceed with caution.

#17
89
2011 Honda RidgelineLOWA-

A uniquely capable and highly reliable 'truck-ish' vehicle, provided you address its few known Achilles' heels proactively.

#18
89
2013 Honda RidgelineLOWA-

A uniquely capable and highly dependable truck that demands a thorough rust inspection before purchase.

#19
89
2020 Honda RidgelineLOWA-

A supremely practical and comfortable truck alternative boasting Honda's hallmark reliability.

#20
89
2021 Honda RidgelineLOWA-

This unibody pickup offers exceptional reliability and comfort, with minor risks primarily tied to an important recall and modern tech.

Top pick

1995 Toyota Tacoma

92/100

"A truly bulletproof truck if you find a rust-free example and address known safety recalls and wear items proactively."

All scores follow our 7-factor methodology.

Ranked list is a starting point. A full report is the finish line.

Every vehicle above has a full reliability report with repair costs, mileage danger zones, and "what I would do" guidance. Pick your year and see the detail.

OwnerKeep Passport

Bought one of the best? Treat it like one.

OwnerKeep Passport turns every receipt, photo, and service into a luxury digital ownership vault — with an OwnerScore that pays you back at resale.

  • AI receipt OCR — snap and log
  • Fuel & mileage tracker
  • Tri-Score OwnerScore
  • One-tap resale dossier PDF
$499 · one-time · lifetime access · no subscription