2019 Toyota Tacoma vs 2025 Toyota Tacoma
Reliability Side-by-Side
2019
Toyota Tacoma
Grade A-
A supremely tough and reliable truck, if you can live with its quirky transmission and less-than-stellar fuel economy.
2025
Toyota Tacoma
Grade B-
A highly anticipated redesign that promises capability, but new technology means potential early-ownership teething issues.
Best For
Best for Reliability
2019 Toyota Tacoma
Score 88/100 vs 82/100
Best for Lowest Risk
2019 Toyota Tacoma
low risk
Best for Lowest Annual Upkeep
2019 Toyota Tacoma
$420-650
OwnerKeep Passport · $499 · one-time
Your car. Documented. Forever.
Snap a receipt — AI logs it. Build an OwnerScore. Sell with a buyer-ready Passport dossier.
Cost of Ownership
| Line Item | 2019 Toyota Tacoma★ | 2025 Toyota Tacoma |
|---|---|---|
| Annual Maintenance | $420-650 | $450-700 |
| Moderate Repairs | $500-1,800 occasionally (e.g., brakes, suspension refresh, exhaust repair) | $600-1,800 occasionally for out-of-warranty powertrain or complex electrical issues typical of a new generation. |
| MPG (City/Hwy) | 18 / 22 | 23 / 24 |
| MSRP (New) | $25,850 | $32,995 |
Major-failure risk and insurance outlook for each vehicle are in their full reliability reports.
Biggest Risks on Each
2019 Toyota Tacoma
Transmission Shifting Logic
All mileages (inherent characteristic) mi
Fuel Pump Recall (202023-010)
Any mileage, typically 10,000-60,000 before failure mi
Infotainment System Glitches
All mileages (software/hardware limitations) mi
2025 Toyota Tacoma
Powertrain (i-FORCE MAX Hybrid & i-FORCE Turbo)
15,000-45,000 mi
Electrical & Infotainment
5,000-25,000 mi
Initial Production Quality & Fit/Finish
0-10,000 mi
Get the Full Report on Each
7-system breakdown, mileage danger zones, repair costs, and expert verdict for each vehicle.
$4.99 each · Instant delivery · No account required
Editorial Take
The Toyota Tacoma has long been a benchmark in the mid-size pickup truck segment, revered for its rugged capability and unwavering reliability. The 2019 model represents the final years of the highly successful third generation, known for its traditional truck feel and proven durability. The 2025 Tacoma, by contrast, ushers in an entirely new fourth generation, boasting a complete redesign from the ground up with modern engineering, enhanced performance, and a suite of advanced technologies. These two models are frequently compared by buyers weighing the value of a pre-owned, established truck against the benefits of a cutting-edge, newly engineered vehicle, with key decision factors centering on budget, fuel efficiency, ride comfort, and the integration of advanced driver assistance systems. HEAD-TO-
Reliability & Common Issues
2019 Toyota Tacoma: 1. Automatic Transmission Shifting Issues: Some owners of 2016-2020 V6 automatic models reported the transmission exhibiting hesitant shifts, "gear hunting" on inclines, or feeling generally unrefined. While not a widespread failure, it was a common point of contention for many drivers. 2. Weak AC System: A minority of owners experienced issues with the air conditioning system, ranging from inadequate cooling performance in hot climates to specific component failures, sometimes requiring refrigerant recharges or part replacements within the first few years of ownership. 3. Fuel Pump Recall: A widespread recall affected certain 2019 and 2020 Toyota models, including the Tacoma, due to a potentially faulty low-pressure fuel pump inside the fuel tank. This component could fail, leading to engine stalling while driving, increasing the risk of a crash. Affected vehicles were subject to free replacement by Toyota. 2025 Toyota Tacoma: As a newly introduced generation, there are no established common issues or widespread reliability concerns reported. While any all-new vehicle may experience minor "first-year" quirks or software glitches, Toyota's rigorous testing and reputation for quality control suggest that significant problems are unlikely. Future reliability will be closely monitored, but current expectations are high given the brand's track record and the robust TNGA-F platform shared with other durable Toyota trucks.
Value & Cost of Ownership
When new, the 2019 Tacoma was priced competitively within its segment, typically starting in the mid-$20,000s. Today, a used 2019 Tacoma holds its value exceptionally well, often commanding prices in the $30,000 to $40,000 range for well-maintained V6 4x4 models, depending on mileage and trim. This strong resale value is a hallmark of the Tacoma. The 2025 Tacoma, being an all-new generation, carries a higher starting MSRP, beginning in the low $30,000s and quickly climbing with features and powertrains. Insurance costs for both models are generally reasonable for pickup trucks, though the 2025 model may see slightly higher premiums initially due to its higher purchase price and the cost of repairing more advanced technology. Maintenance costs for both generations are expected to be affordable, as Toyota is renowned for its low cost of ownership and robust, easy-to-service components. Routine service intervals are standard. Resale value is where both Tacomas truly shine. The 2019 Tacoma continues to be a segment leader in depreciation, meaning it loses less of its initial value over time compared to many competitors. The 2025 Tacoma is expected to continue this trend, benefiting from Toyota's reputation and the demand for its latest truck technology. While the 2025 model will naturally depreciate from its new vehicle price, its long-term value retention is expected to be excellent, mirroring its predecessor's performance.
Editorial Verdict
Best for families: The 2025 Toyota Tacoma. Its significantly improved ride comfort, more spacious and refined interior, updated infotainment system with advanced connectivity, and comprehensive suite of standard Toyota Safety Sense 3.0 features make it a more comfortable, safer, and technologically advanced choice for family duties, despite the rear seat still being a bit snug for large adults. Best for commuters: The 2025 Toyota Tacoma. The new TNGA-F platform with its coil spring rear suspension delivers a noticeably smoother and more composed ride, which is a major advantage for daily commuting. Improved fuel economy, particularly with the i-FORCE MAX hybrid, and a more comfortable driving position also contribute to a superior commuting experience compared to the 2019 model. Best for enthusiasts: The 2025 Toyota Tacoma. While the 2019 TRD Off-Road and Pro models are highly capable, the 2025 generation elevates the game. Its more powerful and torquey i-FORCE and i-FORCE MAX engines, coil spring rear suspension for better articulation and comfort, and advanced off-road technologies like available front stabilizer bar disconnect, multi-terrain select, and enhanced crawl control, make it the superior choice for serious off-road enthusiasts seeking the latest in capability and performance. Best value overall: The 2019 Toyota Tacoma. For buyers seeking a highly reliable and capable mid-size truck without the premium price tag of a brand-new vehicle, a well-maintained 2019 Tacoma offers exceptional value. Its proven durability, strong resale value, and robust performance ensure a practical and enjoyable ownership experience at a significantly lower initial investment than the redesigned 2025 model. It provides nearly all the core truck functionality at a more accessible price point.
Parts & Accessories for These Vehicles
Products for 2019 Toyota Tacoma
Products for 2025 Toyota Tacoma
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.